Selling silver dollars in Wichita
A few dollars from a dresser drawer or a canvas bag from the farm safe. We check every date and mint mark and price each coin on silver or better.
Dollars on the plains
Silver dollars stayed in everyday use in Kansas longer than in the cities back East. Cattle buyers, grain dealers and small-town banks handled them, and families kept them as savings or gave them as gifts.
We often see dollars in cloth bank bags from Wichita banks and small-town banks around the county, along with dollars wrapped in paper with a date written on top.
Dates that bring more
Some Morgan and Peace dollars carry premiums even when worn.
- Most Carson City Morgans
- 1893-S, 1895 and 1889-CC
- 1903-O and 1904-S
- 1921 high relief Peace dollar
- 1928 and 1934-S Peace dollars
Bags and rolls
A canvas bank bag held a thousand dollars, a roll held twenty. Partial bags, rolls in paper and stacks wrapped in rubber bands all turn up. We count every coin with you and pull out the better ones before pricing the rest as a group.
GSA Carson City dollars
In the 1970s the government sold Carson City dollars from Treasury vaults in black plastic holders with blue boxes and certificates. Kansas buyers picked up plenty. Keep the holder, box and card together, since collectors pay more for complete sets.
Damaged dollars
Dollars that were polished, drilled for jewelry, bent or worn smooth still hold their silver. They lose the collector premium but keep every bit of their silver value.
Eisenhower dollars
Most Ike dollars from the 1970s are copper-nickel and worth face. The S mint collector versions are the only Ikes with 40 percent silver. We sort them from the real silver dollars at the table.
Wrapped and labeled dollars
Older Kansans often wrapped each dollar in paper and wrote the date or the occasion on it: a birthday, a wedding, a first harvest. We keep track of those notes as we sort, so families can hold back the coins with stories attached.
Dollars we buy
- Morgan dollars from 1878 to 1921
- Peace dollars from 1921 to 1935
- Carson City dollars, loose or in GSA boxes
- Rolls and bank bags
- Trade dollars
- Certified dollars
- Silver Eisenhower dollars
How dollars are priced
Every Morgan and Peace dollar holds about 0.77 troy ounces of pure silver. Worn common dates sell a little above that.
Scarce dates, Carson City coins and uncirculated grades bring much more. Any dollar that might bring a premium gets graded under the loupe.
Further reading: How much are my coins worth?
Common questions
- What is a common silver dollar worth?
- Its silver plus a small premium. Better dates and grades bring more.
- Do you buy whole bags?
- Yes. We go through the bag coin by coin with you.
- Should I polish my dollars?
- No. Polishing lowers the value.